Buying advice - multitool, random orbital sander and router

E

elsmandino

Joined
23 Jan 2012
Messages
174
Reaction score
5
Location
Essex
Country
United Kingdom
Hi there.

I have recently got into woodworking and could really do with the following tools to help with my current DIY projects:

* Multitool
* Random Orbital Sander
* Router

As an amateur, I do not need to buy anything absolutely top end but would like to avoid buying anything so cheap that it is a false economy.

Any advice on what models to buy would be much appreciated.

If it helps, I have a Makita cordless drill and driver set. However, I am not convinced that any of the abovementioned tools actually need to be cordless (unless anyone thinks otherwise).

Any pointers would be much appreciated.
 
What size of a budget do you have?
For each item.
Cordless multitool, corded router, corded ROS.
 
i replied on your UKworkshop forum post
www.ukworkshop.co.uk

Buying advice - multitool, random orbital sander and router

Hi there. I have recently got into woodworking and could really do with the following tools to help with my current DIY projects: * Multitool * Random Orbital Sander * Router As an amateur, I do not need to buy anything absolutely top end but would like to avoid buying anything so cheap that...
www.ukworkshop.co.uk www.ukworkshop.co.uk
i find the multi-tool very useful as cordless - just a retired DIYer
And probably the same for the sander

BUT just depends on if happy to plug into an extension lead

if you are already on the Makita battery platform , then maybe worth a look at that range

difficult to say , in my experience buying some of the cheaper triton/lidl power tools - most have failed in some way and returned
So i now tend to buy tools from Dewalt and on the battery platform and for garden Stihl , a bit overkill , but i only want to buy once and when i use want it to work ......
Click to expand...
 
Thank you - apologies for the same post on two different sites.

Budgetwise - if I could spend around £250.00 in total, that would be great, though £300.00 would be OK.

I have had mixed results with Screwfix homebrand products - I bought a McAllister Tracksaw that has been absolutely fine but I have had an old jigsaw that failed (replaced with a Bosch) and also a garden shredder which is barely usable.

I agree that perhaps the multitool should be cordless if possible (though I take it that will whack the costs up a bit).
 
If I were you I would get the Lidl Parkside, all corded.
Not top end but very good value for money.
I have a couple of their tools and they haven't failed yet, despite the abuse they get from me.
Especially the 12 year old mitre saw which for some reason refuses to die and it's still perfectly square.
Maybe because I only use freud blades and know how to use it.
 
johnny2007 said:
If I were you I would get the Lidl Parkside, all corded.
Not top end but very good value for money.
I have a couple of their tools and they haven't failed yet, despite the abuse they get from me.
Especially the 12 year old mitre saw which for some reason refuses to die and it's still perfectly square.
Maybe because I only use freud blades and know how to use it.
Click to expand...
I have had a quick look on the Lidl website (nice to seem Arnie on there) - it is not quite clear how you buy the tools.

Do you have to just wait until they are in stock and pick them up, in person, whilst you can?
 
elsmandino said:
I have had a quick look on the Lidl website (nice to seem Arnie on there) - it is not quite clear how you buy the tools.

Do you have to just wait until they are in stock and pick them up, in person, whilst you can?
Click to expand...
Yup, and if cordless you usually do not get charger, batteries and tool on sale at the same time!, but decent quality, proper LG batteries etc. I went for the aldi versions as they were available sooner when I started looking.
 
Maybe start with a palm router , fairly cheap £40 should buy one .
I would spend the most on the orbital sander , having had lots of cheap sanders I found a Makita 6” model well worth the £150 .Of the three tools the sander will likely be the most used .

Cordless Oscillating Multi Tool, 18V Brushless Multifunction Tools Compatible with Makita 18V Battery, 6 Variable Speed, 22 Accessories for Removal, Scraping, Cutting and Polishing
https://amzn.eu/d/8WyNaK5
 
Last edited:
So do you know what you need these tools to do? Without us knowing that you will get as many different answers as people giving feedback.

Dust control or do you already have that sorted? If not then it's something you need to consider as part of being tools. I recommend that you buy a Class M one.

My thoughts are with a £300 budget are as follows.

Tools you are asking about. Will you always have mains power available? Around the house that is normal. Outside less so.

Router - for me the only choice for a general purpose, only machine to own is a Triton MOF001. It's mid-power delivered with 1/4inch and 8mm collets but 1/2 collet is available and the machine has enough 'grunt' to the majority of work you wish to do (although, sometimes you have to make more multiple cuts to complete the work). It will work as a Fixed Base and Plunge router. we are talking around £230 for that.
The other routers in the Triton range less powerful and lighter or a Kg or so heavier. Many other makes/machines are Plunge only.

Multi tools - Low price tools you are looking around £75 whether Mains or Battery, to stay on the Makita battery platform - £130.

The Sander - do you have a specific requirement for ROS? Such I say are very much a finishing sander and not a general purpose tool - they will take much longer to smooth off timber. I'd suggest a 1/3 sheet orbital sander with dust extraction is better value. I would recommend you buy one from a good tool shop - things you need to consider is commonality of sanding sheet dust hole punchings, power dust extraction, connection to separate dust extractor.

I know I'm talking a lot about dust control but it is important and your lungs will thank you for considering it now.
 
I have two multitools, both are corded. I only do domestic work and it is seldom that I find myself working anywhere without power. If working outdoors, I just use an extension lead.

I can see why people working on proper building sites value cordless tools, but cordless drills/drivers aside, I have never seen the need to be cordless. Whenever possible, I connect my tools to my corded dust extractors. I am tethered by the vacuum hose, I don't see what I would gain by paying more for a cordless version of a tool that is physically connected to another tool.

Getting back to multitools. I have only ever used two cordless ones, a fein which was fine but over the OP's budget and my stepson's new Ryobi One- I was trying to cut through moisture resistant chipboard. It kept cutting out after 30 or so seconds. I ended up using my corded Fein.
 
Makita do a good cordless multi tool, it’s a great benefit not to have a trailing cord, the router and sander are better corded
 
Diver Fred said:
So do you know what you need these tools to do? Without us knowing that you will get as many different answers as people giving feedback.

Dust control or do you already have that sorted? If not then it's something you need to consider as part of being tools. I recommend that you buy a Class M one.

My thoughts are with a £300 budget are as follows.

Tools you are asking about. Will you always have mains power available? Around the house that is normal. Outside less so.

Router - for me the only choice for a general purpose, only machine to own is a Triton MOF001. It's mid-power delivered with 1/4inch and 8mm collets but 1/2 collet is available and the machine has enough 'grunt' to the majority of work you wish to do (although, sometimes you have to make more multiple cuts to complete the work). It will work as a Fixed Base and Plunge router. we are talking around £230 for that.
The other routers in the Triton range less powerful and lighter or a Kg or so heavier. Many other makes/machines are Plunge only.

Multi tools - Low price tools you are looking around £75 whether Mains or Battery, to stay on the Makita battery platform - £130.

The Sander - do you have a specific requirement for ROS? Such I say are very much a finishing sander and not a general purpose tool - they will take much longer to smooth off timber. I'd suggest a 1/3 sheet orbital sander with dust extraction is better value. I would recommend you buy one from a good tool shop - things you need to consider is commonality of sanding sheet dust hole punchings, power dust extraction, connection to separate dust extractor.

I know I'm talking a lot about dust control but it is important and your lungs will thank you for considering it now.
Click to expand...
100% agree with Diver Fred

actual tools depend on your requirements for example furniture manufacture may be chopsaw table saw and router
house renovation chopsaw sander jigsaw buzzy toy for example
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top