Replacement Battery

Joined
11 Jan 2004
Messages
43,322
Reaction score
2,758
Country
United Kingdom
I usually buy Varta or Bosch (essentially the same), but in an attempt to spend less, someone said, why don't you look at the warranty period and buy the cheapest?

So I'm looking at Exide on Tayna's website.

As far as I can tell, for a 096 standard battery, they have 3:

Excell 71/ 670 3 year warranty for around £70.

Premium 72/ 720 4 year for 74.
Premium 77/ 770 4 year for 86.

By comparison,

A Varta 70/ 640 3 year is 91.
A Bosch 70/ 640 3 year is 99.

A Varta or Bosch 77/ 780 5 year is 101 or 102.

Does it really matter which I get?

Would I regret going for the cheapest Exide?
 
Can't advise on car batteries, but I choose Lucas and Yuasa for my wife's scooter AGM batteries for what that may be worth. Exide have been in the battery game for a long time, of course.
 
My experience with o.e. or major-branded batteries is they last 7 - 10 years, so to that extent the minimum guarantee period is irrelevant I have no experience of other non-branded makes, but would tend to think they will not be so long-lived because :

1) unlike some products /brands (Nike etc )batteries do not have huge promotional budgets which add significantly to the price of leading makes.
2) They are well-established "plodder" products where companies live with a normal margin which reflects their costs/quality.

Below is a review of Exide ( picked at random )


The non-American Exide activities were bought out of a bankruptcy by Atlas Holdings, a financial company in 2020 and so i believe that cost-cutting rather than product-performance/quality will be their goal.
 
This Numax 110 was on my car when I bought it. After six years, I replaced it with this Yuasa 5110. The Numax was still good but because I sometimes leave my car for months on end, I decided to put a new one on. I think the old one was just as good as the new one.
 
Seems to me that as long as you avoid Halfords own brands you're ok, as mentioned batteries seem to last ages these days. I've only just changed mine (Golf 120K 10 years old).
 
Well, we've had the car from new (2009), but the original battery was goosed as the car sat around for around 18m or so. I swapped it for a Bosch S6 AGM in late 2010 or early 2011 (I can't remember which). It was on special and an absolute steal, so I went for it, despite the car not being S/S. We made a deal with the dealer over the cost. It's still OK, but when it's very cold, you can tell it's struggling a bit.
Hence I thought I might think about replacing it before it fails altogether. To me, a car is a tool enabling you to earn and it's no use to man or beast if it fails, so you have to keep it in good shape. The car currently has around 180K on the clock.
 
Yep sounds like it's time for the battery, when they last so long what's the point in putting it off, I ended up very desperate as it happens, I've known for about a year or more the battery was wearing down and then in a cold snap in January this year I could tell it was barely working and I absolutely need my car every day, so I paid over the odds for a new battery to be fitted that day at a VW specialist (needed to be coded) but as it turned out they had to mess with some other stuff so glad I went where I went in the end, my new battery will undoubtedly outlast the car now.
 
Last edited:
You don't say what model your car is, but some modern's (BMW for one) rely heavily on good battery voltage, not just the ability to start the car.

The only thing that concerns me about buying online is should the battery develop a fault under warranty, will the supplier expect you to return such a bulky & heavy item for examination, at your expense?
 
Tayna seems to have bought out Manchester batteries, and Lucas is long gone, it was part of British Leyland. But battery life has more to do with how it is cared for.
Although Lucas supplied BL with a lot, I don't think they were anything to do with them

The name still exists. Owned by trw group I believe
 
AGM batteries need a slightly different charging regime to regular flooded wet lead acids. Thus a regular smart charge of the current battery would be in order to keep it in tip top order if the vehicle charging system is too 'conservative' to fully charge it?

Might be worth taking to a motor factor-battery sales place for a conductance test to see what capacity and CCA it has to compare with the 'when new' spec? They may even be competitive price wise.

Halfrauds leisure batteries had a good rep at one time and 'them in the know' said they were a rebadged top quality brand (but my memory has forgotten which).
 
The name still exists. Owned by trw group I believe
After LucasVarity was sold to TRW the Lucas brand name was licensed for its brand equity to Elta Lighting for aftermarket auto parts in the United Kingdom. The Lucas trademark is currently owned by ZF Friedrichshafen, which retained the Elta arrangement.

from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_Industries

 
During Colvid the cars were not used much, but the car still contacts Jaguar and runs things even when switched off, so the battery slowly discharges.

I found some completely flat batteries when moving house, and tried to recharge them, one failed, but around three recovered, but the smart battery charger will not charge a battery under around 7 volt as it assumes it's a 6 volt battery, and at around 15 volt it auto turns off, as it assumes the battery is disconnected, so only way to charge a completely flat battery is to connect it in parallel to a good battery.

This allows the charger to work, and since interested I plugged the charger into an energy monitor so I could see what happened over time.

So to start with the charger toped up the good battery, then turned the charge rate down to zero, with a few blips, when the good battery had slightly self discharged, but the discharged battery seemingly was doing nothing, this went on for around 10 days, then as if a switch had been flicked, the battery charged and the energy monitor showed it had accepted around it's full AH capacity. This was then repeated with other batteries found, so not a one off.

The point of the story is it takes a long time for a sulphated battery to recover, and the same applies to a part sulphated battery, so every so often I will put the smart charger on the cars battery to remove the build up of sulphur on the plates for around a week, once a vehicle battery has been discharged, the alternator is simply not running for long enough to fully recharge it in most cases, we would need to be doing some silly mileage to have the engine running for that long.

The Jag is easy, if battery fully charged the engine stops at junctions, if it does not stop at junctions, I know it needs a charge, the other cars I normally do after doing the Jag, often only leave on charge a day or two, not the full 10 days, but since retiring I simply don't use the cars enough to keep them charged.

As to selling names, and parts of a company, yes some parts of the British Leyland Group were bought and the name continues, but only the name, I have a bottle of Lucas upper cylinder lubricant made in the USA by Lucas oil products inc. Clearly not the Joseph Lucas we all knew those years ago. The Lucas trademark is currently owned by ZF Friedrichshafen. It though it's life changed with links with CAV and Bosch and combined and split many times, so hard to now work out what bits are what.

But we are talking about the name, not the product, and my updates to my Lucas work shop manual and data manual stopped years ago in spite saying it had a live time update system.
 
Back
Top