Ok what should the Israelis have done after the 7 th October ??
It's OK to kill journalists
- Thread starter JohnD
- Start date
Ok what should the Israelis have done after the 7 th October ??
Why do you think that is relevant to killing journalists?
did you mean to suggest that violence in response to an attack is justified?
- Joined
- 31 May 2016
- Messages
- 15,782
- Reaction score
- 2,371
- Country
under threat of more violence and in response to an act of war by its neighbour.
What would you suggest they did?
What would you suggest they did?
- Joined
- 31 May 2016
- Messages
- 15,782
- Reaction score
- 2,371
- Country
JohnD pretends not to understand now. Make yourself a cup of tea and calm down a bit. It's not nice when people call you a racist and a liar, when you believe you are innocent. But count to 10 and you will be able to answer the question.
Following the attacks from Hamas on 7-oct which resulted in around 1200 people being killed and from an aggressor whose stated aim is to kill all jews and delete Isreal, an aggressor who's military capability is intertwined in civilian infrastructure and has who in doing so has declared war on Isreal. What is your advice to them?
Try not to answer it with a question or a statement on how interesting the question is.
Following the attacks from Hamas on 7-oct which resulted in around 1200 people being killed and from an aggressor whose stated aim is to kill all jews and delete Isreal, an aggressor who's military capability is intertwined in civilian infrastructure and has who in doing so has declared war on Isreal. What is your advice to them?
Try not to answer it with a question or a statement on how interesting the question is.
I'd suggest that if they join a killing journalists thread, they post about killing journalists.
Are you embarrassed about Israel's policy of killing journalists?
Do you want to divert attention from the number of journalists Israel has killed?
Don't you like conversations about Israel killing journalists?
Do you think killing journalists to prevent news getting out is wrong?
Is killing journalists something you want to hide under a pile of irrelevant posts?
Are you embarrassed about Israel's policy of killing journalists?
Do you want to divert attention from the number of journalists Israel has killed?
Don't you like conversations about Israel killing journalists?
Do you think killing journalists to prevent news getting out is wrong?
Is killing journalists something you want to hide under a pile of irrelevant posts?
- Joined
- 31 May 2016
- Messages
- 15,782
- Reaction score
- 2,371
- Country
Q1 there is no such policy, so no
Q2 reporting in war zones comes with risk
Q3 many innocent people are killed in wars, some choose to go in to a war zone, some have no choice
Q4 Yes and I also think people should take care not to put themselves in the line of fire
there we go another 4 of your questions answered to zero of mine.
Q2 reporting in war zones comes with risk
Q3 many innocent people are killed in wars, some choose to go in to a war zone, some have no choice
Q4 Yes and I also think people should take care not to put themselves in the line of fire
there we go another 4 of your questions answered to zero of mine.
So you don’t have an answer as to what the Israelis should have done after October 7th ??
Do you know if the next potential government of the uK ( labour ? ) designate Hamas as a terrorist organisation ?
Does the eU designate Hamas as a terrorist organisation ? Do you know ??
I understand your difficulty / dilemma
Do you have any evidence that the killing of journalists is official Isreali government policy ?
Last edited:
Do you have any evidence that it isn't? You think it is just coincidence?
Mark Regev denies it, and he lies more consistently than Boris.
Have you looked at the evidence I already posted?
No, of course you haven't.
No I don’t have any evidence that it is not
But if you or others were to want them to answer in court than the onus or burden of proof is on you
You have not presented any evidence at all that it
Is official Israeli government policy to deliberately murder / target / kill journalists
None what so ever
Does the Uk / EU designate Hamas as a terrorist organisation ?
Is the UK under labour going to alter that classification ?? Probably could ( Brexit)
- Joined
- 31 May 2016
- Messages
- 15,782
- Reaction score
- 2,371
- Country
Karen from Facebook is not evidence of a policy.
A policy would need a memo or document, secret or otherwise. Soldiers ready to whistleblow that they are under orders to shoot journalists, witnesses seeing press people being specifically targeted on missions.
Some these journalists were in vehicles along with those operating weaponised drones.
A policy would need a memo or document, secret or otherwise. Soldiers ready to whistleblow that they are under orders to shoot journalists, witnesses seeing press people being specifically targeted on missions.
Some these journalists were in vehicles along with those operating weaponised drones.
Is that how you describe a Palestinan who is already in Palestine, and has moved to a so-called safe zone, and is targeted by a deadly drone attack?
Do you think killing drones attack civillians randomly?
I don't know your friend Karen. Show me her post.
- Joined
- 31 May 2016
- Messages
- 15,782
- Reaction score
- 2,371
- Country
Do you think a journalist places himself in danger of being killed, if he shares a vehicle with Hamas Combatants who are engaged in an active mission? Or do you think the vehicle is blown up because it has journalists in it.