Most Likely Causes Of Clunking From NS Front Hub Suspension?
- Thread starter ReganAndCarter
- Start date
Tell me about it. Couldn't work out why all the clips were vanishing. Then I tried squeezing the boot's bellows and comparing to the one on other side. The problem boot is quite stiff plastic, but other side is more rubbery and gives a lot more.
Any idea what type of boot I should get, as I won't know what material it's made of until I get it? Are universal ones better? I was thinking about getting a kit with cone and lube to slide boot over cone and joint? Suppose those type of boots are very flexible.
Last edited:
I have a diagnosis - at least a most likely cause diagnosis. Not an easy one this. Took it to my usual MOT centre and they put it on the MOT ramps and gave the front wheels a workout with the shaker (what a tool that is!). Then lots of looking, rattling wheel/spring, levering, look under bonnet. Then more levering and another go on the shaker. Definitely not ball joint (no movement in it), AR bar or bushes. Was in there 20 mins.
Said it's feels like it's high up, so most likely top strut mount. I realise it's a difficult thing to positively identify, due to location/access. Think it was a process of elimination.
If the strut mount, is it ok to drive and do they fail, causing death and destruction? Or just do it ASAP?
What do I replace? Just the bearing, or the big metal plate that holds it all together - or both?
FYI - the spring on strut is 18 months old, but rest of strut is original - 19 years old/108,000 miles.
Said it's feels like it's high up, so most likely top strut mount. I realise it's a difficult thing to positively identify, due to location/access. Think it was a process of elimination.
If the strut mount, is it ok to drive and do they fail, causing death and destruction? Or just do it ASAP?
What do I replace? Just the bearing, or the big metal plate that holds it all together - or both?
FYI - the spring on strut is 18 months old, but rest of strut is original - 19 years old/108,000 miles.
ROLLING BEARING, SUSPENSION STRUT SUPPORT MOUNTING LEMFÖRDER 31419 01 FRONT AXLE | eBay
LEMFÖRDER 31419. Fitting Position Front Axle. Quantity per axle 2. Fitting Position Left and right. PART NO31419 01. Are you sure that this part will fit Your vehicle?. If any doubts, just send us your vehicle identification number (VIN) and our highly qualified advisors will check and confirm!
www.ebay.co.uk
Top Strut Mounting Front Left FOR SCUDO 10->ON CHOICE2/2 2.0 Diesel 270 272 | eBay
Multiple choices exist for:FIAT SCUDO 2.0. FOR FIAT SCUDO. Fitting Position:Front Axle,Left. This is an original quality part manufactured by Febi Bilstein. Weight [Kg]:1,700. Weight [g]:1.700 kg.
www.ebay.co.uk
Last edited:
- Joined
- 25 Jul 2022
- Messages
- 10,707
- Reaction score
- 803
- Country
It's generally the bearing part that fails but you never really know until its all off to inspect it. But generally the bearing will be noisy so if no noise it's likely its the rubber.I have a diagnosis - at least a most likely cause diagnosis. Not an easy one this. Took it to my usual MOT centre and they put it on the MOT ramps and gave the front wheels a workout with the shaker. Then lots of looking, rattling wheel/spring, levering, look under bonnet. Then more levering and another go on the shaker. Definitely not ball joint (no movement in it), AR bar or bushes. Was in there 20 mins.
Said it's feels like it's high up, so most likely top strut mount. I realise it's a difficult thing to positively identify, due to location/access. Think it was a process of elimination.
If the strut mount, is it ok to drive and do they fail, causing death and destruction? Or just do it ASAP?
What do I replace? Just the bearing, or the big metal plate that holds it all together - or both?
FYI - the spring on strut is 18 months old, but rest of strut is original - 19 years old/108,000 miles.
ROLLING BEARING, SUSPENSION STRUT SUPPORT MOUNTING LEMFÖRDER 31419 01 FRONT AXLE | eBay
LEMFÖRDER 31419. Fitting Position Front Axle. Quantity per axle 2. Fitting Position Left and right. PART NO31419 01. Are you sure that this part will fit Your vehicle?. If any doubts, just send us your vehicle identification number (VIN) and our highly qualified advisors will check and confirm!www.ebay.co.uk
Top Strut Mounting Front Left FOR SCUDO 10->ON CHOICE2/2 2.0 Diesel 270 272 | eBay
Multiple choices exist for:FIAT SCUDO 2.0. FOR FIAT SCUDO. Fitting Position:Front Axle,Left. This is an original quality part manufactured by Febi Bilstein. Weight [Kg]:1,700. Weight [g]:1.700 kg.www.ebay.co.uk
They don't usually fail suddenly or dramatically, but it has happened. Definitely sooner than later but if its only light play it shouldn't be critical for a bit.
As for cv boots the stretchy universal ones are good, but they come in a range of sizes so get 1 that's right sized. If using a cone, use silicone on it to help the boot slide. Can be very tough if they grab and not slide. I think it's First line or mafco I use for them (but don't use first line for much else)
Do NOT use the split boots that glue together. Total waste of time and energy
- Joined
- 25 Jul 2022
- Messages
- 10,707
- Reaction score
- 803
- Country
Not fully true. No specific area of test, but comes under suspension mounting/bush.
It does have to be bad and excessive to warrant a fail though
| (c) A shock absorber bush excessively worn | Major |
| (a) A spring: (i) insecurely attached to chassis or axle (ii) with fixings loose to the extent that relative movement is visible | Major Dangerous |
Not what my inspector told me, and my bearing was really bad..
No drama at all, they are very progressive and the worst that can happen is the steering feel becomes clunky.
- Joined
- 25 Jul 2022
- Messages
- 10,707
- Reaction score
- 803
- Country
He could also fail it under a manually raised fault ( not specifically covered in the manual) and label it as Dangerous to drive if he felt it was that bad.
Did he put it as an advisory item even ?
- Joined
- 25 Jul 2022
- Messages
- 10,707
- Reaction score
- 803
- Country
Have you ever changed changed such a bearing? I have...
The strut centre bolt also has to fail, and/or the three turret bolts too, for the strut top to detach..
- Joined
- 25 Jul 2022
- Messages
- 10,707
- Reaction score
- 803
- Country
Yes. And had 2 struts totally fall out the housing, allowing 1 wheel to lean out at around 45%.
Not common, but will try and find you a picture
- Joined
- 25 Jul 2022
- Messages
- 10,707
- Reaction score
- 803
- Country
Not true sorry
We will have to agree to disagree, because the only way they can fail dangerously and catastrophically, is for the top of the strut to force its way through the top of the turret/inner wing.
- Joined
- 25 Jul 2022
- Messages
- 10,707
- Reaction score
- 803
- Country
I'm only a mechanic and mot tester so yes we will have to disagree
Did mine last week as said earlier, the noise (of the spring jamming and freeing as described by Harry) was certainly disconcerting. When I googled it there was suggestion that ignoring it could result in the spring snapping.
I replaced both parts as it was only £20.
Not too bad a DIY job but you'll need coil spring compressor and possibly an impact wrench to remove the strut nut - personally I don't have much luck with those splines in the piston!
I replaced both parts as it was only £20.
Not too bad a DIY job but you'll need coil spring compressor and possibly an impact wrench to remove the strut nut - personally I don't have much luck with those splines in the piston!